How To Choose A Saxophone
Congratulations! You are about to buy your first Saxophone...
Choosing which Saxophone to buy can be exciting, if not a little bit daunting. As part of our ‘Beginner’s Guide To Learning The Saxophone’ series, this section will help you start your journey as you mean to go on.
Things you should know before buying your first Saxophone
So, you have decided you’d like to try your hand at learning to play the saxophone (excellent instrument choice!), and are now faced with the task of choosing your first model. If you are new to the joys of practical musicianship, this may seem like a potentially daunting minefield to navigate.
Fear not, however, for there are some guidelines which if followed, can help ensure that this is an exciting process rather than one tinged with trepidation. When searching for a saxophone model that is appropriate for entry-level players, you might like to consider the following points:
- Which type of saxophone should I start on?
- Build quality
- Budget: How long will this instrument serve me and my goals?
Must I consider everything?! Mouthpiece/Reeds/Ligature/Neckstrap/Instrument
Help, where do I begin?!
The first decision you will have to make, before looking at websites for shiny new/second-hand saxophone treasures, is which of the four key members of the saxophone family would be best to start on: soprano, alto, tenor or baritone (or the bari as it is often known). This is a very important point of consideration and there is a reason why alto, followed by tenor, is the most commonly played instruments.
Accessibility, Price and Comfort
Why exactly, you may ask, are the bookend family members of soprano and baritone generally discounted in this instance? Primarily, this is due to accessibility (i.e. how quickly you will likely get ‘up and running’) and physical comfort, as well as price.
The soprano sax is a tiger in disguise(!), for though it is the sweet cherry atop of the mellifluous saxophone tonal collective, it requires a good level of general sax technique and aural training in order to play ‘in tune’, and as such, can potentially lead to bad habits if the player has not yet established a solid technical foundation in their playing (e.g. ‘biting’ of the mouthpiece leading to jaw ache; insecure/inaccurate pitch awareness).
The bari sax is generally discounted at the beginner level, in large part due to its price (vintage instruments aside, these are comparatively more expensive than their smaller brothers and sisters), as well as the physical demands of playing, given the weight of the instrument (which can cause neck/backache) and the amount of air that is required to play it (this can cause light-headedness in the inexperienced player).
Age and Type of Music
Having now settled on the middle two saxophones of the family, then, which should you choose as ‘the one’ for you: alto or tenor?
Firstly, this may well depend on your age, given that there are important physical considerations to be made. That is, we wouldn’t recommend learning to play the saxophone (regardless of type) before the age of 8 or 9, given the physical demands required in terms of neck/back strength, hand span, and breathing capacity. As the student grows, so should their general comfort, stability and physical ability (in relation to breath production and control), in relation to their saxophone playing.
Secondly, the type of music you’d like to explore may impact the alto vs tenor dilemma. For, there is a far larger catalogue of ‘classical’, recital-style music available for the former, compared to the latter. Whilst this won’t really affect your initial musical studies, this is a consideration if you have specific longer-term goals that are stylistically informed.
I would always recommend that alto be the entry point model for young beginners.
Should the student be older in age and/or bigger physically, then the tenor may equally serve as a starting instrument.
All of this said the good news is that aside from more nuanced differences that creep in at intermediate-advanced level and beyond, the skills you learn on any of the four saxes are entirely transferable to the others. So, the soprano/alto/tenor/bari choice you make as a beginner does not have to dictate your lifelong musical path hereon in…
Does build quality matter?
The general answer to this question would be ‘yes’. As with most things in life, you ‘will get what you pay for’ when it comes to purchasing a saxophone. That said, it is unrealistic to expect all beginners to want to spend their life savings on a piece of metal that they have no present experience of playing (and so requires a certain leap of faith!), and you do not need to in order to acquire an instrument suitable for beginning your studies.
What you do want, though, is an instrument of solid workmanship, made of robust metal which is unlikely to dent or scratch easily and with keys/pads that seal efficiently reliable mechanistic build, and is relatively well in tune (the saxophone has a naturally idiosyncratic pitch centre and this is one of the elements that tends to be better/worse depending on the value of the instrument). Plus, of course, you want an instrument that produces a tonal quality that you are happy with.
Before we move on to the nitty-gritty of instrument specifics, there is one more question worthy of reflection as you consider what saxophone will be ‘right’ for you….
In tandem with thoughts on build quality, it would be advisable to reflect on your saxophone-related goals. Admittedly, you may not yet know what your specific aims are and (for the moment at least) may want to learn to play simply for pleasure.
However, we would at least encourage you to consider two things: (1) how long you may wish to play your model of sax before you are willing to upgrade. For, the better you become (we’re talking years rather than months), the more restrained you will become by a beginner level instrument, (2) whether you may be hoping to play with other musicians. As mentioned previously, the better the instrument model, the better the intrinsic pitch, which will make a huge difference when playing with others.
Having now reflected on the type of saxophone you want to start with, and the notion of build quality and initial saxophone-related goals, we have arrived at the exciting point of equipment-specifics…
Must I consider everything?!
We have arrived! So, you’re at the shop/site, ready to splash the cash on something special. Here is the point at which we need to zoom in on all the goodies you will find inside your instrument case and consider whether there are any additional purchases relating to these that will further enhance your saxophone journey.
The following recommendations cover alto and tenor models, are specific to beginner saxophonists, and would last most players until the intermediate stage:
How To Choose A Saxophone - Summary
- Alto, followed by tenor, are the most common beginner saxes. If you are an adult beginner then the only questions you really need to consider before making your choice are: which sound do you prefer (have some fun getting sucked into a YouTube/Spotify black hole as you research this!), what is your budget (tenors tend to be a little more pricey – vintage models aside, which we wouldn’t recommend for beginners anyway) and how much do you want to explore classical/exam material (in which case, go with alto)
- Build quality will go hand in hand with price
- Strongly consider upgrading your mouthpiece at the outset as the ones that come with a new beginner instrument are typically low grade and not very nice in sound (which doesn’t go hand in hand with motivation)!
- Start with reeds of 1.5/2 strength and look after them with your life!
- You may want to experiment with neck strap and ligature a little further down the line, for comfort reasons
Sign up Below – Or Miss Out…
Every Friday, I distribute a unique email showcasing the four most amazing things I’ve reviewed or used that week.
We guarantee no spam. Just one individual email message, each week, with some excellent ideas and useful information on anything I’ve discovered that I believe you’ll like. It might be music, instruments, ebooks, gadgets. Anything. So long as it’s excellent.
Become a member of our online community and enjoy the 4-Feature Friday email by subscribing below.
Read the next post in this series: