Selecting a recorder isn’t just a simple task; it’s an exciting journey into the world of music, where I get to be the conductor! Whether I’m just starting out or already skilled, finding the right recorder is essential for creating beautiful melodies.
With options like wood for a warm, rich tone and plastic for durability and consistency, each recorder types offer a unique experience. So, I’m setting off on the melodic quest of learning ‘How To Choose A Recorder Instrument,’ where the joy of music meets the thrill of exploration.
Are you ready to discover the world of recorder instruments with me? Let’s keep reading and explore this musical journey together!
Types of Recorder
Recorders come in all shapes and sizes! The recorder society lists ten different members of the recorder family, but most beginners start with a descant recorder or a tenor recorder. However, there are lots of other options if you want to play a more unusual member of the recorder family. You can of course buy a full range of different sized recorders if you like!
Common recorder sizes:
- Descant Recorder
- Soprano Recorder
- Alto Recorder
- Tenor Recorder
Two very important questions when shopping for a recorder are “how small are your hands?” and “how long are your arms?”. For smaller players, a descant or treble recorder will be more comfortable than tenor or bass recorders, because they will be easier to play for small hands. Very small players could even try a soprano recorder.
Who will you be playing your recorder with? If you are hoping to join a recorder ensemble then it might be a good idea to find out whether they have spaces for a particular member of the recorder family, such as an alto or bass recorder. Or they might have too many soprano recorder players. This might affect your instrument choice.
Wooden Recorder v Plastic Recorder
Know your audience! Recorders are a popular musical instrument choice for young children because it can be a great introduction to playing a woodwind instrument. If you are buying for a child then a plastic or resin recorder is a good buy, because they are very resilient to being accidentally dropped or knocked.
If you are buying for an adult or for more experienced recorder players then you may want to consider wooden recorders, because the sound quality is much better!
- These can be a good option for smaller players as they are lighter and more sturdy.
- You can get plastic recorders in a wide range of colours and finishes which can be fun.
- Can be great if you are buying for a recorder group or class at school - very easy to sterilize between uses!
- You sacrifice some sound quality and they are more difficult to play with good intonation and a wide range of dynamics.
- You can have problems with moisture in plastic recorders as it is not breathable like wood.
- Some are poor quality, always go with a familiar brand such as Yamaha.
Recorders made of hardwood offer the best tone quality but are also more expensive. A good middle ground between plastic and hardwood recorders are softwood recorders. These are made from cherry, maple or pear wood. These are still affordable but offer a much better tone than plastic instruments, and can be a great instrument to learn to play as a beginner.
It is also good to decide a budget before you start shopping for instruments, because they can vary in cost dramatically. Recorders can range from just a few pounds to thousands of pounds. I think this is good advice for buying anything, not just musical instruments!
Styles of Recorder
Pitch:
A440HZ or standard pitch: This means that the recorder will be at concert (modern) pitch. This is best for beginners.
A415HZ or Baroque pitch: This instrument will be in tune with other baroque instruments but not modern pitch instruments (like a piano). Great for playing with baroque strings or harpsichord.
A392HZ or French Baroque: This is even lower than standard Baroque pitch but works well for French baroque recorder music (as the name suggests!)
Fingering Systems:
German Fingering System: The German system is sometimes used for beginners, but it can be a little restrictive as you progress because there are limited fingering patterns.
Baroque fingering system: Most recorders use the Baroque (sometimes called English) finger patterns and it makes sense to use this if possible because it is so widely used.
Renaissance fingering system: This is used for earlier music and has a wide range of fingering combinations so can be quite complicated for a beginner.
Stained or unstained wooden instruments? This doesn’t affect the sound so you can choose whichever you think looks nicest!
What are Double Holes? – Some starter models will only have single finger holes for certain keys. Double holes make it possible to play all the possible notes on the recorder in tune so it is a good thing to look out for
Recorders best for beginners
The Yamaha 20 Series recorders are designed with new recorder players in mind and the straight wind way offers an ideal amount of resistance which makes sound production a breeze with great playability.
Yamaha YRS20BB
Soprano Recorder
COMES WITH: Starter package
FEATURES: Made from ABS resin for durability. Loads of colours available
Yamaha YRS20BB
Soprano Recorder
- Made from ABS resin
- Come in a variety of bright colours which can be very appealing for younger players and adults alike
- Can be dismantled into 3 parts (head joint, body and foot).
- Comes with a handy carry case and fingering chart.
- These are definitely budget range soprano recorders.
- Sound quality can be a little harsh.
When you click ‘Check Price’, you’ll see there are loads of great places to buy this item. Our personal favorite is Sweetwater for the US, and Thomann and Gear4Music for the UK & Europe.
They are the largest music retailers, with excellent customer service, competitive prices, really fast shipping, and the longest guarantees.
The professional musician who wrote this article combined many things,
from the product build, manufacturer’s reputation through to feedback
from other users, to create our famous TedScore™.
Aulos 503B Symphony
Descant Recorder
COMES WITH: Starter package
FEATURES: Adjustable thumb rest and curved windway for extra comfort
Aulos 503B Symphony
Descant Recorder
- Made from hard wearing ABS resin.
- Ivory coloured mouthpiece, rings and footjoint are visually appealing.
- Free blowing sound
- Excellent tuning for a starter model
- The concave bell helps to produce a clear and resonant sound. This is a step up from a budget recorder but is still a very affordable option.
- Can look a little serious for kids
When you click ‘Check Price’, you’ll see there are loads of great places to buy this item. Our personal favorite is Sweetwater for the US, and Thomann and Gear4Music for the UK & Europe.
They are the largest music retailers, with excellent customer service, competitive prices, really fast shipping, and the longest guarantees.
The professional musician who wrote this article combined many things,
from the product build, manufacturer’s reputation through to feedback
from other users, to create our famous TedScore™.
The Moeck 4200 Rottenburgh recorders are named after the Belgian recorder maker Jean-Hyacinth-Joseph Rottenburgh, and were designed by Friederich von Huene. If you want to invest in a high quality and reliable wooden instrument then this is the model for you. It will last for years of music making, and you can tell it’s been crafted by experienced wooden recorder makers.
Moeck 4200
Rottenburgh Soprano
COMES WITH: Starter package
FEATURES: Great dynamic range and a beautiful tone across all registers
Moeck 4200
Rottenburgh Soprano
- Comfortable silicone keys.
- Plastic body is durable and completely washable so great for classroom music lessons.
- Available in several colour options as the silicone keys come in pink, green and blue which offer a lovely contrast to the black body.
- Not a traditional recorder!
When you click ‘Check Price’, you’ll see there are loads of great places to buy this item. Our personal favorite is Sweetwater for the US, and Thomann and Gear4Music for the UK & Europe.
They are the largest music retailers, with excellent customer service, competitive prices, really fast shipping, and the longest guarantees.
The professional musician who wrote this article combined many things,
from the product build, manufacturer’s reputation through to feedback
from other users, to create our famous TedScore™.
Nuvo are famous for producing innovative and stylish instruments which push the boundaries of what is expected. The Nuvo recorder is no different because it is a fully keyed instrument which makes squeaky recorders a thing of the past! Although traditionalists may not be able to get on board with this new design I believe it is worth considering, because they only cost fractionally more than a budget keyless plastic recorder, but offer a much better sound.
Definitely not a recorder for the traditionalists so could be a disadvantage depending on your teacher or audience. However I think they can be exciting for those who want something different from their new recorder though.
Make your mind up on this controversial instrument after watching this fun video of the Nuvo recorder + in action!
Nuvo Recorder+
COMES WITH: Starter package
FEATURES: Great dynamic range and a beautiful tone across all registers
Nuvo Recorder+
- Available in a variety of woods to suit different budgets.
- Great value for wooden recorders
- Well respected design.
- Excellent tuning for a starter model
- Great for ensemble and solo performances due to their resonant sound.
- Pricey for new starters
When you click ‘Check Price’, you’ll see there are loads of great places to buy this item. Our personal favorite is Sweetwater for the US, and Thomann and Gear4Music for the UK & Europe.
They are the largest music retailers, with excellent customer service, competitive prices, really fast shipping, and the longest guarantees.
The professional musician who wrote this article combined many things,
from the product build, manufacturer’s reputation through to feedback
from other users, to create our famous TedScore™.
Upgrading your recorder
If you decide the time is right to upgrade your recorder then it is definitely time to go for a hardwood recorder. This will be a quality instrument which will last you for years of music making.
You could also decide to try a different size of recorder. Perhaps if you started playing a descant recorder then now is the time to try some tenor recorders.
Ask your recorder player friends what instrument they play on and whether they like their instrument. Talk to your teacher about instruments they would recommend and the advantages and disadvantages of different models.
Most retailers offer a returns policy so you can try out the instrument before you commit to buying it.
How to choose a recorder
Summary
I’ve gathered some handy tips to help you choose the best recorder instrument, so you’re all set to make a good decision!
When it comes to comfort, sound, and style, consider the soothing pitch of an alto recorder for beginners or the warm timbre of a tenor for a deeper tone. Both plastic and wood recorders have their charms. Plastic recorders are durable and easy to maintain, while wooden recorders offer a rich, authentic sound.
When making your choice, think about playability and maintenance. Choosing a recorder is a personal adventure, and it’s okay to trust your instincts along with good advice.
With these tips, you’re ready to start a musical journey. Happy playing – may your new recorder bring forth many splendid melodies!
BEST RECORDER FOR BEGINNERS
Yamaha YRS20B Soprano Recorder
It’s great to be able to buy a first instrument from such a reliable and world famous maker such as Yamaha.
BEST RECORDER FOR SCHOOLS
Nuvo Recorder+
The Nuvo is a practical and innovative instrument. It will make your school recorder club stand out from the crowd!
BEST RECORDER FOR ADULTS
Moeck 4200 Rottenburgh Soprano
The Moeck 4200 is a quality instrument made from traditional wood, perfect for solo or ensemble playing.
Wooden recorder? Next you’ll tell me they make them out of dragon bone.
If you find a dragon bone recorder, count me in! Maybe it’ll cast a spell on my music skills.
I purchased a plastic recorder for my grandson after reading your article, Chloë Vincent. He’s absolutely thrilled with it and I’m amazed at how resilient it is. Reminds me of my own childhood music lessons, albeit mine were with a considerably less forgiving wooden recorder!
Can anyone suggest where to find a quality tenor recorder that’s not too pricey? Looking for something durable but won’t break the bank.
Loved the bit about hardwood recorders! Gonna save up for one. Thanks for the tip, Chloë Vincent!
This article made my daughter very happy. Best Dad Ever!
Hi Peter aka Best Dad! Glad it helped…